OWASP Periodic Table of Vulnerabilities - Insufficient Transport Layer Protection
Insufficient Transport Layer Protection
Root Cause Summary
Not all traffic flowing between two endpoints is properly secured, which makes it possible for attackers to perform man-in-the-middle attacks.
Browser / Standards Solution
Implement HTTP Strict Transport Security in all browsers, which makes it possible to better enforce secure connections. Implement Certificate and Public Key pinning in browsers where applicable.
- Make sure that SSL is properly configured on the server:
- Disable all weak SSL/TLS protocols (such as SSLv2)
- Disable all weak 'export' algorithms (such as DES, RC4-40, DHE-RSA-Export)
- Make sure that the minimum session key size is 128 bits
- Use a SSL certificate with a minimum key size of 2048 bits
- Do not use MD5 as cryptographic hash algorithm
- Do not use the RC4 algorithm
- Disable anonymous key establishment algorithms (Anonymous Diffie-Hellman, aNULL)
- Disable algorithms offering no encryption (NULL, eNULL)
- Enforce HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS)
- Redirect all HTTP request to HTTPS
Generic Framework Solution
Custom Framework Solution
Custom Code Solution
Discussion / Controversy
- HTTP Strict Transport Security is at the entry-level maturity, a proposed standard. Not all browsers implement it (yet).
- The security of ciphers changes over time, so it's important to periodically review whether certain ciphers and minimum key sizes are still considered safe enough.
- Certificate and Public Key Pinning is a relatively new technique and not widely used or implemented. Google Chrome's browser is one of the first major browsers to use this technique.
- According to NIST SP800-52, RC4 is "acceptable for use [..] where secure information is to be transferred [..] and 3DES or better (e.g., AES) is not supported by the server".
- According to the RFC 7465 the use of RC4 is prohibited in TLS. This applies to all TLS Versions. "This document requires that Transport Layer Security (TLS) clients and servers never negotiate the use of RC4 cipher suites when they establish connections."
Insufficient Transport Layer Protection (OWASP)
Insufficient Transport Layer Protection (WASC TC)
Guidelines for the Selection and Use of Transport Layer Security (TLS) Implementations (NIST SP 800-52)
HTTP Strict Transport Security (IETF)
Certificate and Public Key Pinning (OWASP)
Google Chrome implements certificate pinning (Google)