Project Information:template Backend Security Project - Final Review - Second Reviewer - F

From OWASP
Revision as of 10:33, 10 December 2008 by Spyro (Talk | contribs)

(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to: navigation, search

Clik here to return to the previous page.

FINAL REVIEW
PART I

Project Deliveries & Objectives

OWASP Backend Security Project's Deliveries & Objectives

QUESTIONS ANSWERS

1. At what extent have the project deliveries & objectives been accomplished? Having in consideration the assumed ones, please exemplify writing down those of them that haven't been realised.

The goals of the project have been met with the delivered content.

2. At what extent have the project deliveries & objectives been accomplished? Having in consideration the assumed ones, please quantify in terms of percentage.

100%

3. Please do use the right hand side column to provide advice and make work suggestions.

The overall content is great. I think that the wiki and the pdf could use more formatting. With the Content section of the wiki it would be nice to have a link to each subsection. This is mainly because as the document grows it will become required for easy navigation. The PDF needs two things. The first is a clickable index like in documents created with PDF writer. The second is code boxing. This is where people put boxes/outlines around code which makes it easier to read.

PART II

Assessment Criteria

OWASP Project Assessment Criteria

QUESTIONS ANSWERS

1. Having into consideration the OWASP Project Assessment Methodology which criteria, if any, haven’t been fulfilled in terms of Alpha Quality status?

All Alpha quality criteria have been met except for the mailing list. This may be in place and I am just unaware of it. If this is so, then there should be a link on the project page for people to join so that they are also aware that they can get updates on the project.

2. Having into consideration the OWASP Project Assessment Methodology which criteria, if any, haven’t been fulfilled in terms of Beta Quality status?

This document meets the Beta Quality criteria

3. Having into consideration the OWASP Project Assessment Methodology which criteria, if any, haven’t been fulfilled in terms of Release Quality status?

This project does not meet Release quality standards set forth by OWASP.

4. Please do use the right hand side column to provide advice and make work suggestions.

Great job on the project. It has very good interlinking to other OWASP documents which makes research easy.