Securing tomcat

Status
 * Content should provide a link and references to  - SecureTomcat - http://securetomcat.googlecode.com Released 14/1/2007

Author
Darren Edmonds

Introduction
Most weaknesses in Apache Tomcat come from incorrect or inappropriate configuration. It is nearly always possible to make Tomcat more secure than the default out of the box installation. What follows documents best practices and recommendations on securing a production Tomcat server, whether it be hosted on a Windows or Unix based operating system. Please note that the section ordering is not a representation of the section importance.

Software Versions
The first step is to make sure you are running the latest stable releases of software;
 * Java Runtime Environment (JRE) or SDK
 * Tomcat
 * Third-party libraries

Many software projects, including Tomcat and Java, maintain multiple branches. New features are added to more recent branches, the older branches receive only bug-fixes and security updates. This allows developers to advance the software without disrupting production environments. Be aware of which branch you have deployed, and track new releases within that branch.

For example, if you are running Tomcat 5.5.26, you should watch for new versions within the 5.5 branch (e.g. 5.5.27) and upgrade to this bug-fix version. If you are content to stick with the Tomcat 5.5 branch then it is not necessary to upgrade to a new 6.0.18 version.

You should subscribe to announcement lists for Tomcat, and any other software you deploy, to stay abreast of new versions released due to security issues. As soon as a security issue is disclosed, potential attackers will begin trying to exploit that vulnerability. It is important that you upgrade your software before an attacker uses the vulnerability against you.

UNIX

 * Create a tomcat user/group
 * Download and unpack the core distribution (referenced as CATALINA_HOME from now on)
 * Change CATALINA_HOME ownership to tomcat user and tomcat group
 * Change files in CATALINA_HOME/conf to be readonly (400)
 * Make sure tomcat user has read/write access to /tmp and write (300 - yes, only write/execute) access to CATALINA_HOME/logs

Windows

 * Download the core windows service installer
 * Start the installation, click Next and Agree to the licence
 * Untick native, documentation, examples and webapps then click Next
 * Choose an installation directory (referenced as CATALINA_HOME from now on), preferably on a different drive to the OS.
 * Choose an administrator username (NOT admin) and a secure password that complies with your organisations password policy.
 * Complete tomcat installation, but do not start service.

Common

 * Remove everything from CATALINA_HOME/webapps (ROOT, balancer, jsp-examples, servlet-examples, tomcat-docs, webdav)


 * Remove everything from CATALINA_HOME/server/webapps (host-manager, manager). Note that it can be useful to keep the manager webapp installed if you need the ability to redeploy without restarting Tomcat.  If you choose to keep it please read the section on Securing the Manager WebApp.


 * Remove CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/host-manager.xml and CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/manager.xml (again, if you are keeping the manager application, do not remove this).

default org.apache.catalina.servlets.DefaultServlet  debug 0   listings false &lt;!-- make sure this is false --&gt;  <load-on-startup>1</load-on-startup>
 * Make sure the default servlet is configured not to serve index pages when a welcome file is not present. In CATALINA_HOME/conf/web.xml


 * Remove version string from HTTP error messages by repacking CATALINA_HOME/server/lib/catalina.jar with an updated ServerInfo.properties file. Note that making this change may prevent Lambda Probe (popular Tomcat monitoring webapp) to initialise as it cannot determine the Tomcat version.  A solution to this can be found on the Lambda Probe Forum. An alternative to repackaging the JAR is available on the Discussion page.


 * unpack catalina.jar

cd CATALINA_HOME/server/lib jar xf catalina.jar org/apache/catalina/util/ServerInfo.properties
 * update ServerInfo.properties by changing server.info line to server.info=Apache Tomcat
 * repackage catalina.jar

jar uf catalina.jar org/apache/catalina/util/ServerInfo.properties
 * remove CATALINA_HOME/server/lib/org (created when extracting the ServerInfo.properties file)

<error-page> <exception-type>java.lang.Throwable</exception-type> /error.jsp </error-page>
 * Replace default error page (default is stacktrace) by adding the following into CATALINA_HOME/conf/web.xml. The default error page shows a full stacktrace which is a disclosure of sensitive information.  Place the following within the web-app tag (after the welcome-file-list tag is fine). The following solution is not ideal as it produces a blank page because Tomcat cannot find the file specified, but without a better solution this, at least, achieves the desired result.  A well configured web application will override this default in CATALINA_HOME/webapps/APP_NAME/WEB-INF/web.xml so it won't cause problems.
 * Rename CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml to CATALINA_HOME/conf/server-original.xml and rename CATALINA_HOME/conf/server-minimal.xml to CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml. The minimal configuration provides the same basic configuration, but without the nested comments is much easier to maintain and understand.  Do not delete the original file as the comments make it useful for reference if you ever need to make changes - e.g. enable SSL.

<Connector port="8080" ... server="Apache" /> &lt;!-- server header is now Apache --&gt;
 * Replace the server version string from HTTP headers in server responses, by adding the server keyword in your Connectors in CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml


 * Start Tomcat, deploy your applications into CATALINA_HOME/webapps and hope it works!

Protecting the Shutdown Port
Tomcat uses a port (defaults to 8005) as a shutdown port. What this means is that to stop all webapps and stop Tomcat cleanly the shutdown scripts make a connection to this port and send the shutdown command. This is not as huge a security problem as it may sound considering the connection to the port must be made from the machine running tomcat and the shutdown command can be changed to something other than the string SHUTDOWN. However, it's wise to take the following precautions; &lt;Server port="8005" shutdown="ReallyComplexWord"&gt;
 * if you are running a publicly accessible server make sure you prevent external access to the shutdown port by using a suitable firewall.
 * change the shutdown command in CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml and make sure that file is only readable by the tomcat user.
 * if this is still a big problem for you then check this thread, from the Tomcat mailing list, for alternatives (they all involve code customisation though).

Securing Manager WebApp
<user username="darren" password="ReallyComplexPassword" roles="manager"/>
 * By default there are no users with the manager role. To make use of the manager webapp you need to add a new role and user into the CATALINA_HOME/conf/tomcat-users.xml file.

<user-data-constraint> <transport-guarantee>CONFIDENTIAL</transport-guarantee> <user-data-constraint>
 * When you access the password-protected manager webapp, the password you enter will be sent over the network in (nearly) plain text, ripe for interception. By using an SSL connection instead, you can transport the password securely.  Fortunately, this is simple to accomplish.  After configuring an SSL Connector in server.xml (see your Tomcat documentation), simply add the following to CATALINA_HOME/webapps/manager/WEB-INF/web.xml inside of the <security-constraint></security-constraint> tags.
 * This will force an SSL connection to be used when accessing the manager webapp. Plus, with a little more work, the SSL Connector can be configured to require a client certificate.

&lt;!-- allow only LAN IPs to connect to the manager webapp --&gt; &lt;!-- contrary to the current Tomcat 5.5 documation the value for allow is not a regular expression --&gt; &lt;!-- future versions may have to be specified as 192\.168\.1\.* --&gt; <Valve className="org.apache.catalina.valves.RemoteAddrValve" allow="192.168.1.*" />
 * Using a valve to filter by IP or hostname to only allow a subset of machines to connect (i.e. LAN machines). Add one of the following within the Context tag in CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/manager.xml

&lt;!-- allow only LAN hosts to connect to the manager webapp --&gt; &lt;!-- contrary to the current Tomcat 5.5 documation the value for allow is not a regular expression --&gt; &lt;!-- future versions may have to be specified as *\.localdomain\.com --&gt; <Valve className="org.apache.catalina.valves.RemoteHostValve" allow="*.localdomain.com" />


 * Rename the manager webapp.
 * This is 'security through obscurity'. Although widely maligned, obscurity is a useful adjunct security measure on a one-off basis. A would-be attacker seeking to gain access to the manager webapp will look for it in its usual location.  By renaming it, you force the attacker to guess URLs or assume that it is not installed.  It is important to note that you are not relying upon this obscurity for security, but rather using it as a backup measure in case someone finds a way around the remote valve filter you have configured as described above.


 * To rename the manager webapp, decide on the new name (we'll use foobar in this example), and:


 * Move CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/manager.xml to CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/foobar.xml
 * Update the docBase attribute within CATALINA_HOME/conf/Catalina/localhost/foobar.xml to ${catalina.home}/server/webapps/foobar
 * Move CATALINA_HOME/server/webapps/manager to CATALINA_HOME/server/webapps/foobar

Logging
As of tomcat 5.5 logging is now handled by the commons-logging framework allowing you to choose your preferred logging implementation - log4j or standard JDK logging. By default the standard JDK logging is used (or a compatible extension called juli to be more precise), storing daily log files in CATALINA_HOME/logs.

By default additional webapp log entries are added to CATALINA_HOME/logs/catalina.YYYY-MM-DD.log and System.out/System.err are redirected to CATALINA_HOME/logs/catalina.out. To place webapp log entries in individual log files create a logging.properties file similar to the following within CATALINA_HOME/webapps/APP_NAME/WEB-INF/classes (change the APP_NAME value to create a unique file for each webapp)

handlers = org.apache.juli.FileHandler, java.util.logging.ConsoleHandler org.apache.juli.FileHandler.level = ALL org.apache.juli.FileHandler.directory = ${catalina.base}/logs org.apache.juli.FileHandler.prefix = APP_NAME.

Further details on logging configuration can be found in the tomcat logging documentation.

If you find you get logging output duplicated in catalina.out, you most likely have unnecessary entries for java.util.logging.ConsoleHandler in your logging configuration file.

Encryption

 * SSL for password or other sensitive data exchange (bordering on application security, not specific to tomcat)
 * SSL for connections (JDBC, LDAP, etc ..)
 * The Tomcat documentation clearly explains how to enable SSL.

Running Tomcat with a Security Manager
The default Tomcat configuration provides good protection for most requirements, but does not prevent a malicious application from compromising the security of other applications running in the same instance. To prevent this sort of attack, Tomcat can be run with a Security Manager enabled which strictly controls access to server resources. Tomcat documentation has a good section on enabling the Security Manager.

It's always a good idea to start tomcat with the "-security" parameter. This also makes sure (among other things), that a webapplication isn't able to read/write/execute any file on the local filesystem without enabling it in the catalina.policy file. This effectively stops web shells like described here from working.

Miscellaneous

 * Tomcat Security FAQ

Using Port 80
If you are on a Windows machine you will be able to change the port attribute of the connector within the Catalina service from 8080 to 80. This allows you to use tomcat directly to serve all requests. Depending on your requirements it may not be good enough to serve directly from Tomcat so you may like to consider;
 * Use IIS / Apache running on port 80 and mod_jk to proxy requests to Tomcat

On a UNIX machine only root is allowed to run services on ports below 1024 (kernel recompilation can overcome this). It is a very bad idea to run Tomcat as root, so the options are (in no particular order); Each of the above options may bring extra security concerns which are outside the scope of this document.
 * Use Apache running on port 80 and mod_jk (or mod_proxy_ajp) to proxy requests to Tomcat
 * Run Tomcat as root, but in a chroot jail
 * Use a tool like authbind to enable a non root user to bind to ports below 1024
 * Use a port forwarder such as Iptables to redirect incoming requests from 8080 to 80. This has the disadvantage that internal redirects still need to use 8080.
 * Run Squid as a web accelerator in front of Tomcat
 * Use JSVC/procrun

Cleartext Passwords in CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml
When configuring a resource, such as a JDBC pool, it is necessary to include clear text username and password in CATALINA_HOME/conf/server.xml Best practices advice us never to store clear text passwords, but the following paragraphs highlight it is very difficult to avoid.

If one way encryption was used on the password it must be possible for a database connection to be established using a username and encrypted password - so the encrypted password is just as valuable as the clear text one to an attacker.

If two way encryption was used a keyfile is needed which must also live on the filesystem. To make it more secure a passphase is added to the keyfile which then has to be stored in the configuration as clear text - no improvement.

Encoding is security by obscurity and offers no form of protection (algorithms can be reverse engineered). What encoding does do is make huge amounts of overhead work - you need to customise Tomcat and the commons digester it uses to parse the config files. You'd also need a way to create encoded passwords.

In the case of a JDBC pool what you can do is;
 * make sure the database user only has access to the databases and tables they need (also limit rights as necessary).
 * make sure the raw database files are only accessible to the user running the database services (e.g. mysql/postgresql user)
 * make sure the Tomcat configuration files are only accessible to the tomcat user

Acknowledgements
The author would like to thank Kris Easter, Michel Prunet and Stephen More for their valuable input.