Cross-User Defacement

ASDR Table of Contents

Description
An attacker can make a single request to a vulnerable server that will cause the sever to create two responses, the second of which may be misinterpreted as a response to a different request, possibly one made by another user sharing the same TCP connection with the sever. This can be accomplished by convincing the user to submit the malicious request themselves, or remotely in situations where the attacker and the user share a common TCP connection to the server, such as a shared proxy server. In the best case, an attacker can leverage this ability to convince users that the application has been hacked, causing users to lose confidence in the security of the application. In the worst case, an attacker may provide specially crafted content designed to mimic the behavior of the application but redirect private information, such as account numbers and passwords, back to the attacker.

This attack is rather difficult to carry out in the real environment. The list of conditions is long and hard to accomplish by the attacker.

Cross-User Defacement attack is possible because of HTTP Response Splitting and flaws in the web application. It is crucial from the attacker's point of view that the application allows for filling the header field with more than one header using CR (Carrige Return) and LF (Line Feed) characters.

Risk Factors
TBD

Examples
We have found a web page, which gets service name from the "page" argument and then redirects (302) to this service.

E.g. http://testsite.com/redir.php?page=http://other.testsite.com/

And exemplary code of the redir.php: rezos@spin ~/public_html $ cat redir.php  Crafting appropriate requests: /redir.php?page=http://other.testsite.com%0d%0aContent- Length:%200%0d%0a%0d%0aHTTP/1.1%20200%20OK%0d%0aContent- Type:%20text/html%0d%0aContent- Length:%2019%0d%0a%0d%0a deface HTTP server will respond with two (not one!) following headers:

1 HTTP/1.1 302 Moved Temporarily Date: Wed, 24 Dec 2003 15:26:41 GMT Location: http://testsite.com/redir.php?page=http://other.testsite.com Content-Length: 0 2 HTTP/1.1 200 OK Content-Type: text/html Content-Length: 19 deface If user shares a TCP connection (e.g. proxy cache) and will send a request:

/index.html

the response #2 will be send to him as an answer to his request.

This way it was possible to replace the web page, which was served to the specified user.

More information can be found in one of the presentations under http://www.owasp.org/images/1/1a/OWASPAppSecEU2006_HTTPMessageSplittingSmugglingEtc.ppt

Related Threat Agents

 * TBD

Related Attacks

 * HTTP Response Splitting
 * Cache Poisoning

Related Vulnerabilities

 * Category:Input Validation Vulnerability

Related Controls

 * Validation of the input data (CR and LF).
 * Forbid HTTP headers nesting in one header's field.
 * Category:Input Validation