Blind SQL Injection

Last revision (mm/dd/yy): //

Description
Blind SQL (Structured Query Language) injection is a type of SQL Injection attack that asks the database true or false questions and determines the answer based on the applications response. This attack is often used when the web application is configured to show generic error messages, but has not mitigated the code that is vulnerable to SQL injection.

When an attacker exploits SQL injection, sometimes the web application displays error messages from the database complaining that the SQL Query's syntax is incorrect. Blind SQL injection is nearly identical to normal SQL Injection, the only difference being the way the data is retrieved from the database. When the database does not output data to the web page, an attacker is forced to steal data by asking the database a series of true or false questions. This makes exploiting the SQL Injection vulnerability more difficult, but not impossible. .

Threat Modeling
Same as for SQL Injection

Risk Factors
Same as for SQL Injection

Examples
An attacker may verify whether a sent request returned true or false in a few ways:

Content-based
Using a simple page, which displays an article with given ID as the parameter, the attacker may perform a couple of simple tests to determine if the page is vulnerable to SQL Injection attacks.

Example URL: http://newspaper.com/items.php?id=2 sends the following query to the database: SELECT title, description, body FROM items WHERE ID = 2  The attacker may then try to inject a query that returns 'false': http://newspaper.com/items.php?id=2 and 1=2 Now the SQL query should looks like this: SELECT title, description, body FROM items WHERE ID = 2 and 1=2 If the web application is vulnerable to SQL Injection, then it probably will not return anything. To make sure, the attacker will inject a query that will return 'true': http://newspaper.com/items.php?id=2 and 1=1 If the content of the page that returns 'true' is different than that of the page that returns 'false', then the attacker is able to distinguish when the executed query returns true or false.

Once this has been verified, the only limitations are privileges set up by the database administrator, different SQL syntax, and the attacker's imagination.

Time-based
This type of blind SQL injection relies on the database pausing for a specified amount of time, then returning the results, indicating successful SQL query executing. Using this method, an attacker enumerates each letter of the desired piece of data using the following logic:

If the first letter of the first database's name is an 'A', wait for 10 seconds.

If the first letter of the first database's name is an 'B', wait for 10 seconds. etc.

Microsoft SQL Server http://www.site.com/vulnerable.php?id=1' waitfor delay '00:00:10'--

MySQL SELECT IF(expression, true, false) Using some time-taking operation e.g. BENCHMARK, will delay server responses if the expression is True.

BENCHMARK(5000000,ENCODE('MSG','by 5 seconds')) - will execute the ENCODE function 5000000 times.

Depending on the database server's performance and load, it should take just a moment to finish this operation. The important thing is, from the attacker's point of view, to specify a high-enough number of BENCHMARK function repetitions to affect the database response time in a noticeable way.

Example combination of both queries: 1 UNION SELECT IF(SUBSTRING(user_password,1,1) = CHAR(50),BENCHMARK(5000000,ENCODE('MSG','by 5 seconds')),null) FROM users WHERE user_id = 1; If the database response took a long time, we may expect that the first user password character with user_id = 1 is character '2'. (CHAR(50) == '2') Using this method for the rest of characters, it's possible to enumerate entire passwords stored in the database. This method works even when the attacker injects the SQL queries and the content of the vulnerable page doesn't change.

Obviously, in this example, the names of the tables and the number of columns was specified. However, it's possible to guess them or check with a trial and error method.

Databases other than MySQL also have time-based functions which allow them to be used for time-based attacks:
 * MS SQL 'WAIT FOR DELAY '0:0:10''
 * PostgreSQL - pg_sleep

Conducting Blind_SQL_Injection attacks manually is very time consuming, but there are a lot of tools which automate this process. One of them is SQLMap (http://sqlmap.sourceforge.net/) partly developed within OWASP grant program. On the other hand, tools of this kind are very sensitive to even small deviations from the rule. This includes:


 * scanning other website clusters, where clocks are not ideally synchronized,
 * WWW services where argument acquiring method was changed, e.g. from /index.php?ID=10 to /ID,10

Remote Database Fingerprinting
If the attacker is able to determine when his query returns True or False, then he may fingerprint the RDBMS. This will make the whole attack much easier. If the time-based approach is used, this helps determine what type of database is in use. Another popular methods to do this is to call functions which will return the current date. MySQL, MSSQL, and Oracle have different functions for that, respectively now, getdate, and sysdate.

Related Threat Agents
Same as for SQL Injection

Related Attacks

 * Blind_XPath_Injection
 * SQL_Injection
 * XPATH_Injection
 * LDAP_injection
 * Server-Side_Includes_%28SSI%29_Injection

Related Vulnerabilities

 * Injection_problem

Related Controls

 * Category:Input Validation

See the OWASP Development Guide article on how to Avoid SQL Injection Vulnerabilities. See the OWASP SQL Injection Prevention Cheat Sheet.

See the OWASP Code Review Guide article on how to Review Code for SQL Injection Vulnerabilities.

See the OWASP Testing Guide article on how to Test for SQL Injection Vulnerabilities.