Reviewing Code for Session Integrity issues

OWASP Code Review Guide Table of Contents

Introduction
Cookies can be used to maintain a session state. This identifies a user whilst in the middle of using the application. Session Id's are a popular method of identifying a user. A "secure" session Id should be at least 128 bits in length and sufficiently random. Cookies can also be used to identify a user but care must be taken in using cookies. Generally it is not recommended to implement a SSO (Single Sign on) solution using cookies; they were never intended for such use. Persistent cookies are stored on a user hard disk and are valid depending on the expiry date defined in the cookie. The following are pointers when reviewing cookie related code.

How to locate the potentially vulnerable code
If the cookie object is being set with various attributes apart from the session ID check the cookie is set only to transmit over HTTPS/SSL. In java this is performed by the method: cookie.setSecure (Java) cookie.secure = secure; (.NET) Response.Cookies("CookieKey").Secure = True (Classic ASP)

HTTP Only Cookie
This is adhered to in IE6 and above... HTTP Only cookie is meant to provide protection against XSS by not letting client side script accessing the cookie. Its a step in the right direction but not a silver bullet.

cookie.HttpOnly = true (C#)

Here cookie should only be accessible via ASP.NET.

Notice HTTPOnly property is not supported in Classic ASP pages.

Limiting Cookie Domain
Ensure cookies are limited to a domain such as example.com. Therefore the cookie is associated to example.com. If the cookie is associated with other domains the following code performs this:

Response.Cookies["domain"].Domain = "support.example.com"; (C#) Response.Cookies("domain").Domain = "support.example.com" (Classic ASP)

During the review if the cookie is assigned to more than one domain make note of it and query why this is the case.

Displaying Data to user from Cookie
Make sure that data being displayed to a user from a cookie is HTML encoded. This mitigates some forms of Cross Site Scripting. LabelX.Text = Server.HtmlEncode(Request.Cookies["userName"].Value); (C#) Response.Write Server.HtmlEncode (Request.Cookies("userName")) (Classic ASP)

HTML Hidden Field
The HTML Hidden field could be used to perform session tracking. Upon each HTTP POST request the hidden field is passed to the server identifying the user. It would be in the form of



Server-side code is used to perform validation on the VALUE in order to ensure the used is valid. This approach can only be used for POST/Form requests.

URL Rewriting
URL rewriting approaches session tracking by appending a unique id pertaining to the user at the end of the URL.

Click Here

Leading Practice Patterns for Session Management/Integrity
HTTPOnly Cookie: Prevents cookie access via client side script. Not all browsers support such a directive.

Valid Session checking:

Upon any HTTP request the framework should check if the user pertaining to the HTTP request (via session ID) is valid.

Successful Authentication:

Upon a successful login the user should be issued a new session identifier. The old session Id should be invalidated. This prevents session fixation attacks and the same browser also sharing the same session ID in a multi user environment. Some times the session Id is per browser and the session remains valid while the browser is alive.

Logout: This also leads to the idea of why a logout button is so important. The logout button should invalidate the users session Id when it is selected.

Related Articles
http://www.owasp.org/index.php/Category:OWASP_Cookies_Database

http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms533046.aspx

http://java.sun.com/j2ee/sdk_1.3/techdocs/api/javax/servlet/http/Cookie.html